In the ever-evolving field of nursing science, practitioners and researchers constantly seek new ways to improve patient care and advance the nursing profession. One crucial aspect of this pursuit is the integration of borrowed theories into nursing practice and research.
Borrowed theories in nursing refer to conceptual frameworks and models originally developed in other disciplines but adapted and applied to nursing contexts. These theories provide valuable insights and perspectives that can enhance the quality of nursing care, guide research endeavors, and contribute to the overall advancement of nursing as a discipline.
Definition of borrowed theories in Nursing
Borrowed theories in nursing are theoretical frameworks originating from disciplines other than nursing, such as psychology, sociology, or biology, that are applied to nursing situations and used to guide nursing practice, education, and research.
These non-nursing theories are adapted to fit the unique nursing perspective and contribute to the development of nursing knowledge
The use of borrowed theories in nursing research and study is of paramount importance for several reasons:
- Expanding the theoretical foundation: Borrowed theories broaden the conceptual base of nursing, allowing for a more comprehensive understanding of complex health phenomena.
- Interdisciplinary collaboration: By incorporating theories from other disciplines, nursing fosters collaboration and knowledge exchange across various fields of study.
- Enhancing evidence-based practice: Borrowed theories provide a solid theoretical framework for developing and implementing evidence-based interventions in clinical practice.
- Advancing nursing science: The application of borrowed theories contributes to the ongoing development and refinement of nursing-specific theories and models.
- Improving patient outcomes: By leveraging insights from diverse disciplines, nurses can develop more effective strategies for patient care and education.
Read more on The Nursing Process with Gordon’s Model Gordon’s Functional Health Patterns
List of Popular Borrowed Theories in Nursing
While numerous borrowed theories have been adapted for use in nursing, three particularly influential models have gained widespread recognition and application in nursing research and practice.
- General Systems Theory (Ludwig von Bertalanffy, Biology) – Provides a framework for understanding the interrelationships between various components of health systems and patient care.
- Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs (Abraham Maslow, Psychology) – Guides nurses in prioritizing patient needs and understanding motivations for health-seeking behaviors.
- Erikson’s Stages of Psychosocial Development (Erik Erikson, Psychology) – Helps nurses understand patients’ developmental stages and associated health challenges across the lifespan.
- Social Cognitive Theory (Albert Bandura, Psychology) – Used in health promotion and patient education to understand and influence health behaviors.
- Transtheoretical Model of Change (Prochaska & DiClemente, Psychology) – Guides nurses in assessing patients’ readiness for health behavior change and tailoring interventions accordingly.
- Health Belief Model (Rosenstock, Hochbaum, Kegeles, and Leventhal, Public Health)- Helps nurses understand patients’ perceptions of health threats and the likelihood of taking preventive actions.
- Theory of Planned Behavior (Icek Ajzen, Psychology) – Used in health promotion to predict and influence health-related behaviors.
- Stress and Coping Theory (Lazarus & Folkman, Psychology) -Guides nurses in understanding and supporting patients’ stress management and coping mechanisms.
- Attachment Theory (John Bowlby, Psychology) -Informs nursing care in pediatrics, maternal-child health, and mental health settings.
- Social Support Theory (Various contributors, Sociology/Psychology) -Helps nurses understand the importance of social networks in patient recovery and health maintenance.
- Diffusion of Innovations Theory (Everett Rogers, Sociology) -Used in implementing new nursing practices and health technologies.
- Chaos Theory (Edward Lorenz, Mathematics) -Provides insights into complex health systems and unpredictable aspects of patient care.
- Cognitive Dissonance Theory (Leon Festinger, Psychology) -Helps nurses understand and address conflicting health beliefs and behaviors in patients.
- Self-Efficacy Theory (Albert Bandura, Psychology) -Guides nurses in promoting patient confidence in managing their health conditions.
- Ecological Systems Theory (Urie Bronfenbrenner, Developmental Psychology) -Helps nurses consider multiple environmental factors influencing patient health.
- Uncertainty in Illness Theory (Merle Mishel, originally developed for Nursing but borrowed concepts from Psychology) – Guides nurses in supporting patients dealing with the unpredictability of illness trajectories.
- Quality of Life Theory (Various contributors, Psychology/Sociology) -Informs holistic nursing care and patient-centered outcomes.
- Empowerment Theory (Various contributors, Social Work/Community Psychology) -Guides nurses in promoting patient autonomy and self-management of health.
- Transitions Theory (Various contributors, Sociology/Psychology) -Helps nurses support patients through health-related life transitions.
- Cultural Competence Models (Various contributors, Anthropology/Sociology) – Guides nurses in providing culturally sensitive and appropriate care.
How borrowed nursing theories enhance nursing research
The integration of borrowed theories into nursing research has significantly contributed to the advancement of nursing science and the development of evidence-based practice.
Providing a theoretical framework
Borrowed theories offer robust theoretical frameworks that can guide the research process from conceptualization to implementation. These frameworks provide a structured approach to understanding complex nursing phenomena and help researchers organize their thoughts, observations, and findings in a meaningful way.
For example, a nurse researcher studying the impact of chronic illness on family dynamics might use Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory, borrowed from developmental psychology, to examine the various levels of environmental influence on the family unit.
Guiding research questions and hypotheses
Borrowed theories can inspire and shape research questions and hypotheses by highlighting specific aspects of nursing phenomena that warrant investigation. By applying theoretical concepts from other disciplines, nurse researchers can explore new avenues of inquiry and generate novel insights into nursing practice.
For instance, a researcher interested in improving medication adherence among older adults might draw upon the Health Belief Model, borrowed from health psychology, to formulate research questions about patients’ perceived susceptibility to illness and the perceived benefits of medication compliance.
Enhancing the reliability and validity of studies
The use of established theories from other disciplines can enhance the reliability and validity of nursing research by providing well-tested concepts and measurement tools. Borrowed theories often come with validated instruments and established methodologies that can be adapted for use in nursing studies, improving the overall quality and rigor of the research.
For example, a nurse researcher studying stress among intensive care nurses might utilize the Transactional Model of Stress and Coping, borrowed from psychology, to develop a more comprehensive and valid measure of occupational stress in the nursing context.
Application of borrowed nursing theories in nursing research
Borrowed theories have been applied across various types of nursing research, demonstrating their versatility and value in advancing nursing knowledge and practice.
A. Case studies
Case studies provide an in-depth examination of specific nursing situations, allowing researchers to apply borrowed theories to real-world contexts. These studies often involve a detailed analysis of patient experiences, nursing interventions, and outcomes, guided by the concepts and principles of the borrowed theory.
For instance, a case study examining the recovery process of a patient with a spinal cord injury might utilize Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory, borrowed from psychology, to explore the patient’s self-efficacy beliefs and their impact on rehabilitation outcomes.
Quantitative research
Borrowed theories have been extensively used in quantitative nursing research to develop hypotheses, design measurement instruments, and interpret statistical findings. These theories provide a solid foundation for operationalizing variables and establishing relationships between different aspects of nursing phenomena.
For example, a large-scale study investigating the factors influencing nurses’ job satisfaction might employ Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory, borrowed from organizational psychology, to develop a comprehensive survey instrument and analyze the relative importance of various job factors.
Qualitative research
In qualitative nursing research, borrowed theories can serve as interpretive lenses through which researchers analyze and make sense of rich, descriptive data. These theories can guide the development of interview questions, thematic analysis, and the overall interpretation of participants’ experiences.
For instance, a phenomenological study exploring the lived experiences of nurses working in community health settings might draw upon Lewin’s Change Theory, borrowed from social psychology, to examine how nurses adapt to and facilitate change in diverse community contexts.
Challenges of using borrowed nursing theories in research
While borrowed theories offer numerous benefits to nursing research, their application is not without challenges. Researchers must carefully consider several factors when integrating these theories into nursing studies.
Cultural differences
One significant challenge in using borrowed theories is addressing cultural differences between the original context of the theory and the nursing context. Theories developed in Western cultures may not always translate effectively to diverse nursing populations or healthcare settings.
For example, a researcher applying Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs to study patient motivations in a non-Western healthcare setting may need to consider how cultural values and beliefs influence the prioritization of needs and the concept of self-actualization.
Ethical considerations
The application of borrowed theories in nursing research must adhere to ethical principles and guidelines specific to nursing and healthcare. Researchers must ensure that the use of these theories aligns with nursing’s core values and does not compromise patient care or professional integrity.
For instance, when applying theories from business or management to study nursing leadership, researchers must be mindful of the unique ethical considerations in healthcare, such as patient advocacy and the duty of care.
Limitations of the original theory
Borrowed theories may have limitations or assumptions that do not fully align with nursing perspectives or contexts. Researchers must critically evaluate the appropriateness of the theory for nursing research and make necessary adaptations while maintaining the theory’s integrity.
For example, a researcher using Piaget’s Cognitive Development Theory to study pediatric patient education may need to consider how chronic illness or hospitalization might affect the typical stages of cognitive development outlined in the original theory.
Summary of benefits of using borrowed nursing theories in research
The integration of borrowed theories into nursing research has significantly contributed to the advancement of nursing science and practice. These theories have:
- Expanded the theoretical foundation of nursing, allowing for a more comprehensive understanding of complex health phenomena.
- Provided robust frameworks for guiding research questions, hypotheses, and methodologies.
- Enhanced the reliability and validity of nursing studies by offering established concepts and measurement tools.
- Facilitated interdisciplinary collaboration and knowledge exchange.
- Contributed to the development of evidence-based interventions and improved patient outcomes.
Recommendations for future research using borrowed nursing theories
As the field of nursing continues to evolve, researchers should consider the following recommendations for future studies involving borrowed theories:
1. Critically evaluate the appropriateness of borrowed theories for specific nursing contexts and populations.
2. Adapt and refine borrowed theories to better align with nursing perspectives and values.
3. Develop integrative approaches that combine borrowed theories with nursing-specific theories to create more comprehensive frameworks.
4. Conduct cross-cultural studies to assess the applicability of borrowed theories in diverse healthcare settings.
5. Explore the potential of emerging theories from fields such as data science, artificial intelligence, and systems biology for application in nursing research.
6. Encourage collaboration between nurse researchers and experts from other disciplines to foster innovation and knowledge synthesis.
In conclusion, the thoughtful application of borrowed theories in nursing research has the potential to drive significant advancements in nursing science, education, and practice. By leveraging insights from diverse disciplines, nurse researchers can continue to enhance the quality of patient care, contribute to the development of nursing knowledge, and strengthen the foundation of nursing as a unique and vital profession in the healthcare landscape.